Picture two offers side by side. Same pay, same commute. One says “Lead Engineer.” The other says “Software Engineer.” Which do you take?
If you picked the first one before asking what either job actually is, this note is for you.
Over the years I’ve filled seats with all kinds of titles: senior engineer, staff engineer, lead, engineering manager, VP of engineering, CTO. Here’s what all of them taught me. The title matters a little. The work matters a lot.
Do titles matter at all?
Some. A title can show how far you’ve come. It can signal that you’ve led people. At some companies it lines up with a pay band. On a résumé that gets a quick skim, that’s worth something.
But titles mean wildly different things from one company to the next. A senior engineer at a ten-person startup and a senior engineer at a big company may do completely different jobs. A “lead” might lead six people, or one, or mostly a backlog.
What people actually weigh is what you’ve done and what you can do. The title is the label on the jar. Hiring managers open the jar.
What should I look at instead?
The work. What will you build? What problems will you own? Who will you work beside, and who will you learn from? Will this seat stretch you, or just keep you busy?
If those answers are right, the title will catch up. If they’re wrong, a bigger title won’t make Monday mornings any better.
Should I lead a team or stay hands-on?
This is the title question that actually matters, because it’s really a question about your days.
Some engineers thrive as a lead. They like the mix: planning the work, unblocking people, mentoring, and still writing code. Others want to stay deep in the code. Some of the strongest engineers I know have more experience than their team lead and no interest at all in the job. That isn’t a lack of ambition. It’s knowing what you love.
Neither path is the grown-up one. Pick the work you want your days to be made of. If you’re not sure, try leading a project before you sign up to lead a team. (I wrote more about what makes someone senior in What “senior” actually means.)
What if my title doesn’t match my work?
Then say so, kindly. If you’re already doing a lead’s job, it’s fair to ask for the title to match, for accuracy’s sake if nothing else. The next hiring manager will read it.
Just keep the order straight. Get the work right first. Then make the label tell the truth about it.
The short version
- A title signals something, but it means different things at different companies.
- What you build, and who you build it with, matter more.
- Lead or hands-on is the real question. Pick the days you want.
- If your title undersells your work, ask for it to match.
- Never trade a better job for a better label.
Get the work right. The title will catch up, or it won’t matter.
Weighing a bigger title against better work?
I read these myself. Jonathan Soo Hoo, my partner at Mirror, does the first outreach on some searches; if you hear from him, that’s why.