My first slogan was “We hate recruiters, too.” Engineers loved it. Recruiters loved it less: it got me heckled at a charity event, and honestly, I had it coming. I dropped the slogan. The list behind it still stands.
Here’s that list: the habits that gave my profession its reputation, and what I try to do instead.
What do engineers hate about recruiters?
- Not reading your background, and sending you anything with a matching keyword.
- “Someone told me you’d be perfect for this.” (Nobody did.)
- Not knowing what the job actually is, or who it’s for.
- Pitching a job they don’t even represent.
- Sending your résumé to companies without asking you first.
- Pressure to take an offer you’re not sold on.
- Fuzzy, or flat-out wrong, numbers about pay.
What do hiring managers hate?
- Never learning what your company does, or what the seat really needs.
- A stack of résumés that looks like someone threw pasta at the wall to see what sticks.
- Pushing salaries up because a bigger salary means a bigger fee.
- Guarantees that vanish into fine print the moment a hire doesn’t work out.
What does a good recruiter do for an engineer?
- Names the company and the salary range in the first message.
- Sends nothing anywhere without your yes.
- Knows the team, the hiring manager and the work, so you don’t spend an afternoon finding out it’s wrong.
- Speaks up for you when you’re not in the room, and brings back real feedback, not “not a fit.”
- Costs you nothing. The company pays.
- Stays in touch when you’re happy, so the right seat can find you later.
What does a good recruiter do for a hiring manager?
- Learns what the person really does on day one, and what’s keeping you up at night.
- Brings you people you couldn’t reach yourself, usually because they aren’t looking.
- Vets them properly, so you meet a few great people instead of a pile.
- Wants a number both sides feel good about, because offers that stick are the whole point.
- Puts the risk in plain words. Mine is a 100-day guarantee, pro-rated one percent a day. No cliff, no fine print.
So do I still hate recruiters?
No. I’ve met plenty of good ones, and most of the habits on these lists don’t come from bad people. They come from a model that rewards volume. I built mine around fit instead. Twenty years later, that’s still the whole idea.
Hiring? Talk to Brian
An engineer? Say hello
I read these myself. Jonathan Soo Hoo, my partner at Mirror, does the first outreach on some searches; if you hear from him, that’s why.