Brian’s Notes How I work

A wastebasket overflowing with identical form-letter envelopes, and beside it a single handwritten envelope closed with a red wax seal bearing a gem

Why people hate recruiters.

And what a good one does instead.

My first slogan was “We hate recruiters, too.” Engineers loved it. Recruiters loved it less: it got me heckled at a charity event, and honestly, I had it coming. I dropped the slogan. The list behind it still stands.

Here’s that list: the habits that gave my profession its reputation, and what I try to do instead.

What do engineers hate about recruiters?

  • Not reading your background, and sending you anything with a matching keyword.
  • “Someone told me you’d be perfect for this.” (Nobody did.)
  • Not knowing what the job actually is, or who it’s for.
  • Pitching a job they don’t even represent.
  • Sending your résumé to companies without asking you first.
  • Pressure to take an offer you’re not sold on.
  • Fuzzy, or flat-out wrong, numbers about pay.

What do hiring managers hate?

  • Never learning what your company does, or what the seat really needs.
  • A stack of résumés that looks like someone threw pasta at the wall to see what sticks.
  • Pushing salaries up because a bigger salary means a bigger fee.
  • Guarantees that vanish into fine print the moment a hire doesn’t work out.

What does a good recruiter do for an engineer?

  • Names the company and the salary range in the first message.
  • Sends nothing anywhere without your yes.
  • Knows the team, the hiring manager and the work, so you don’t spend an afternoon finding out it’s wrong.
  • Speaks up for you when you’re not in the room, and brings back real feedback, not “not a fit.”
  • Costs you nothing. The company pays.
  • Stays in touch when you’re happy, so the right seat can find you later.

What does a good recruiter do for a hiring manager?

  • Learns what the person really does on day one, and what’s keeping you up at night.
  • Brings you people you couldn’t reach yourself, usually because they aren’t looking.
  • Vets them properly, so you meet a few great people instead of a pile.
  • Wants a number both sides feel good about, because offers that stick are the whole point.
  • Puts the risk in plain words. Mine is a 100-day guarantee, pro-rated one percent a day. No cliff, no fine print.

So do I still hate recruiters?

No. I’ve met plenty of good ones, and most of the habits on these lists don’t come from bad people. They come from a model that rewards volume. I built mine around fit instead. Twenty years later, that’s still the whole idea.

Hiring? Talk to Brian

An engineer? Say hello

Talk to Brian

Tell me what you need. I’ll think of someone.

Skip the formal job description. The more honest you are about the seat, the stack and the room, the faster a warm intro shows up. If I can help, great. If not, I’ll point you in the right direction.

Brian MarianiI read these myself. Jonathan Soo Hoo, my partner at Mirror, does the first outreach on some searches; if you hear from him, that’s why.

When do you need someone in the chair?

No sequence, no platform. A person reads this. Questions first? Read the FAQ.