You’ve done the hard part. You found a seat you’re excited about, you said yes, and you walked in to give notice. Then your boss surprised you. “What would it take to keep you?”
A raise. Maybe a new title. Maybe the project you’ve been asking about for a year. It feels good to be wanted, and it should. Here’s my advice anyway, and I’ll be frank: almost never take it.
Why not, if they’re offering more?
Because money was rarely the reason you started looking. Think back to what it was. A boss you never clicked with. Work that stopped teaching you anything. A company headed somewhere you didn’t want to go.
A raise fixes none of that. Three months later, the bigger paycheck feels normal, and every reason you wanted to leave is still sitting there. More often than not, that’s when we end up talking again.
Doesn’t it mean something that they want me?
It does, just not what you hope. Giving notice is a bit like a breakup. You can try to work it out, but you both know you said it.
Your boss may quietly wonder whether you’re staying for the money, or still looking. Your teammates may wonder, too. Nobody means any harm by it. It’s human. But it sits under every conversation that follows.
Does a counteroffer ever work?
Rarely, and I can tell you when. Over twenty years, the few I’ve seen work all had one thing in common: they were really a new job. A new team, a new boss and new problems, at a company big enough to offer that.
If it’s the same boss and the same team, I’d bet against it.
So what should I do instead?
Have the honest conversation before you look, not after. If something could change and you’d happily stay, ask for it now, while nobody’s holding an offer. That’s the fairest test for you and for your boss, and it’s how lasting changes actually happen.
If you asked and nothing changed, then look. And once you’ve decided to go, for good reasons, stick with the decision.
One more thing: don’t interview just to get leverage where you are. It costs everyone time, and the trust it spends doesn’t come back.
How do I hold the line when the offer comes?
Write down why you’re leaving before you give notice. When the counteroffer arrives, read it back. A good recruiter won’t push you either way, but I will remind you what you told me mattered. A spouse or a good friend is great for this, too.
The short version
- A counteroffer fixes the money. It rarely fixes the reason you looked.
- Once you’ve given notice, things change, even with good people.
- The rare ones that work are really a new job: a new team and a new boss.
- Ask for what you need before you look, not after.
- Never interview just for leverage.
Leave kindly, with thanks, and keep the friendships. Just leave.
Holding a counteroffer and not sure what to do?
I read these myself. Jonathan Soo Hoo, my partner at Mirror, does the first outreach on some searches; if you hear from him, that’s why.