Brian’s Notes If you’re an engineer

An opened envelope with the letter pulled out and its red gem seal broken in two, beside a pen and a phone ready with three reply choices

You got the offer.

How to say yes, no or “almost.”

The email lands late on a Friday. Subject line: “Your offer.” You read it twice, send it to someone you trust, and think about it all weekend. That’s fine. Just don’t think about it all next week, too.

Every offer gets one of three answers: yes, no or “almost.” Each has a right way to say it, and all three share a first rule: answer fast.

How fast should I answer?

As fast as you honestly can. Take the time you need to decide, and not a day more. While an offer sits, the people who made it start to wonder. Is he not that excited? Is she shopping it around? I wrote a whole note on this for hiring managers (Time kills), and it cuts both ways.

If you want to compare offers, plan for that at the start, not the end. Run your conversations side by side. Offers come with deadlines, and the one in your hand won’t wait while you go find another.

How do I say yes?

Quickly, and like you mean it. If the offer is solid and you’re excited, say so. Don’t risk a great seat over a small gap. (That’s Short money, another note in this library.)

Then do one more thing. The signature happens on a screen these days, but call the person who’ll be your boss anyway. Tell them you’re in and you can’t wait to start. It’s the first thing you’ll do as their teammate, and it sets the tone for everything after.

How do I say no?

Kindly, quickly and honestly. Don’t say “I’ll think it over” when you mean no. As soon as you know, tell them, so they can call the next person. They’ll remember that you did.

And tell them why. You know how useless “not the right fit” feels when you’re on the receiving end. If the seat doesn’t match where you’re headed, or you need flexibility they can’t give, say that. An honest no helps them hire better, and it keeps the door open for later.

If I introduced you, tell me first. It’s often easier to be candid with me, and passing along what they should hear is part of my job.

What about “almost”?

Then look at the whole offer, not one number. An offer is a package:

  • Salary
  • Equity and bonus
  • Health coverage
  • Time off
  • Retirement match
  • Where you’ll work: remote, hybrid or in the office
  • Equipment for working from home
  • A signing bonus or relocation

Decide what matters most to you, and where you can bend. Then ask for a trade, not a bump. If you’re covered through your spouse’s health plan, maybe some of what they’d spend on yours can go to salary. If you need a long trip every fall, maybe you can give a little somewhere else. A company that can’t say yes to “a bit more” can often say yes to a thoughtful trade.

If you’re working with me, here’s a tip from years of doing this: tell me the package you’d say yes to. From me, it’s a plan we can work toward. From you, at the last minute, the same number can sound like an ultimatum.

When shouldn’t I negotiate?

When the offer is already good. I’ve watched great engineers talk themselves out of great offers, chasing a number that only existed in their heads. Sometimes the company truly can’t stretch. Even when it can, haggling over a good offer isn’t how you want to start.

Listen to your gut. If it says this is a good offer, you have more to lose than to gain by pushing.

The short version

  • Answer as fast as you honestly can. Offers don’t keep.
  • Yes: say it warmly, then call your new boss.
  • No: say it kindly and quickly, and say why.
  • Almost: negotiate the package, not one number, and offer a trade.
  • If it’s already good, take the yes.

However you answer, answer like someone they’ll be glad they met. You may well meet again.

Weighing an offer and want a second opinion?

Talk to Brian

Say hello. Or just tell me where you’re headed.

You don’t have to be looking. Most of the people I’ve placed weren’t. Tell me what you’re working on and what would make you pick up, and I’ll keep you in mind for the right thing, not the next thing.

Brian MarianiI read these myself. Jonathan Soo Hoo, my partner at Mirror, does the first outreach on some searches; if you hear from him, that’s why.

No sequence, no platform. A person reads this. Questions first? Read the FAQ.