Brian’s Notes If you’re an engineer

A cherry pie on a plate with one slice cut out, a magnifying glass over the cut, and a small key

Equity, in plain words.

What to ask before you count on it.

Almost every startup offer has a line that reads like a lottery ticket: “plus equity.”

Sometimes it’s a real piece of something that grows. Sometimes it’s a nice feeling and a number with no meaning yet. You can’t tell which until you ask a few questions, and most engineers never do. You became an engineer and not an accountant for a reason. I get it.

One thing up front: I’m not a lawyer or a tax advisor, and equity comes with real legal and tax consequences. Use this to know what to ask. Then ask someone qualified about your own situation.

What exactly am I being offered?

Shares, or options?

Shares are a piece of the company. Options are the right to buy shares later, at a set price called the strike price. If the company does well, what an option is worth to you is roughly the difference between what a share sells for and your strike price, minus what it costs you to buy.

So ask which you’re getting. If it’s options, ask the strike price, and what kind of options they are. Different kinds are taxed differently, which is exactly the kind of question to bring to that qualified someone.

What’s my piece of the whole?

A number of shares means nothing on its own. Ten thousand shares sounds wonderful until you learn how many shares exist.

Ask how many shares are outstanding, counting everything that’s been promised, or simply what percentage of the company your grant represents. A good founder will tell you.

Who gets paid before me?

Investors usually hold preferred stock. One of the things preferred stock can buy them is the right to be paid back first if the company is sold.

That matters more than people think. If a company sells for less than its investors put in, the common shareholders, which usually means you, can end up with little or nothing. Ask how much preference sits ahead of you.

What stage is the company at?

Ask which round of funding they’re in, and when they expect to raise again.

Each new round usually means new shares, which shrinks everyone’s percentage. Later stages tend to mean a higher strike price and less risk. Earlier ones mean a bigger possible upside, and a longer road to get there.

When is it really mine?

Equity usually vests over time, often with a cliff before any of it is yours. (Yes, equity usually has a cliff. My guarantee doesn’t. That’s another note.)

Ask about the vesting schedule. Ask how long you’d have to buy your options if you left. And ask what happens to unvested equity if the company is sold.

How big is the pool?

Most startups set aside a pool of shares for the people who work there. Ask how big it is and how much of it has already been granted. It tells you something about how the company thinks about sharing what it builds, and whether the pool may need to grow, which would shrink everyone a little.

So what’s it actually worth?

Nobody knows, and that’s the honest answer. Startup equity swings wildly with every round, every hire and every market.

So play it out. Imagine a great outcome, a middling one and zero. If the offer only works in the first one, give the salary more weight.

The short version

  • Shares or options? If options, at what strike price?
  • What percentage of the company is it?
  • How much preference sits ahead of you?
  • What stage are they at, and how does the vesting work?
  • How big is the pool?
  • Then treat it as upside, and ask a professional about your own situation.

Equity can change a life. It can also be a lovely piece of paper. Ask the questions, and you’ll know which one you’re holding.

Holding an offer with equity in it?

Talk to Brian

Say hello. Or just tell me where you’re headed.

You don’t have to be looking. Most of the people I’ve placed weren’t. Tell me what you’re working on and what would make you pick up, and I’ll keep you in mind for the right thing, not the next thing.

Brian MarianiI read these myself. Jonathan Soo Hoo, my partner at Mirror, does the first outreach on some searches; if you hear from him, that’s why.

No sequence, no platform. A person reads this. Questions first? Read the FAQ.