Brian’s Notes If you’re hiring
You’re buying the pile.
Why your senior opening gets 300 résumés and no hire.
You post the senior seat on a Tuesday. By Thursday there are three hundred applications. By Friday your best engineer has spent two days reading them instead of building, and the shortlist has nobody on it you’d actually want to call.
When I talk with hiring managers, this is what I hear. You’re not doing anything wrong. You’re just buying the pile.
What are hiring managers telling me?
Three things, over and over:
- Hundreds of résumés, and nobody worth a call. They’re polished, often by AI, and they all sound alike. Every one claims the stack, the scale and the leadership. Few hold up past the first real question.
- They can’t tell real from fake. Some applications are written by a machine for a person who isn’t quite who they say they are. Some fake applicants even show up to interviews.
- Their best engineers are buried. The people who should be building spend days screening, and the seat stays empty anyway.
None of this is the applicants’ fault, by the way. Most of them are good people using the tools everyone uses. It’s just that when every résumé is polished, polish stops telling you anything.
Why doesn’t more reach help?
Because every channel reaches the same people. Job boards, LinkedIn, agencies, internal sourcers: they all find people who are looking, and people who apply. Spend more and you get a bigger pile, not a better one.
That’s the trap. It feels like progress, because the numbers go up. But you’re paying, in money and in your team’s time, for more of the same thing.
So where are the engineers I want?
Mostly, they’re happy where they are. They’re busy doing good work for someone else. They don’t scroll job boards, and the recruiter messages piling up in their inbox go unread. They don’t apply.
But they do answer someone they trust. A former boss. A friend from an old team. Someone who has known them for years and knows what would make them pick up. That isn’t a channel you can buy. It’s a relationship somebody built, one conversation at a time.
It’s the whole reason Mirror exists. I’m not searching. I’m texting people I know about a seat I understand.
What can I do instead?
- Ask your own team first. Your best engineers know other great engineers. Ask who they’d love to work with again, and make it easy for them to reach out.
- Describe the seat honestly. Say what this person really does on day one, and what’s keeping you up at night. (More on that in Fifteen minutes.) The right person recognizes themselves in an honest description.
- Go where the trust is. Reach out personally, or work with someone who already has the relationships. A small group of three to five people you’d genuinely want to meet beats three hundred you’ll never finish reading.
Should I stop posting the job?
No. Post it. Some good people do apply, and a clear post helps everyone you talk to understand the seat. Just don’t expect the post to do the finding. For a senior seat, the post is the brochure, not the search.
The short version
- Every channel that reaches applicants reaches the same pile.
- When every résumé is polished, polish tells you nothing.
- The senior engineers you want aren’t applying. They answer someone they trust.
- Start with your own team, describe the seat honestly, and go where the trust is.
Three hundred résumés feels like progress. One message to the right person is progress.
Tired of the pile?
I read these myself. Jonathan Soo Hoo, my partner at Mirror, does the first outreach on some searches; if you hear from him, that’s why.