Brian’s Notes If you’re hiring

A desk set up and waiting for a new hire, with an open laptop, a warm mug and a small plant, under a wall calendar marking the short gap between the yes and the start day, and a wrapped gift box with a red bow off to the side

The counteroffer problem.

And how to get ahead of it.

Your new engineer said yes on Thursday. Her start date is five weeks out. On Friday she walks into her boss’s office to give notice, and her boss asks the question every good boss asks: “What would it take to keep you?”

From that moment until her first day with you, you’re in a quiet competition. Her current company knows her, likes her and has suddenly found a budget. You have a signed offer and an empty chair.

Do counteroffers actually work?

Rarely, and I’ll say so to any engineer who asks. The reasons someone started looking don’t go away with a raise. Over twenty years, the few counteroffers I’ve seen work were really a new job: a new role, with a new boss. (I wrote the engineer’s side in Don’t take the counteroffer.)

But “rarely works for the engineer” is cold comfort to you. The moment a counteroffer is accepted, you’ve lost the hire, whether or not it works out for them. By the time they realize the raise didn’t fix anything, months have passed and you’ve long since moved on, or started the whole search over. So don’t leave the gap to chance.

What should I do between the yes and the start date?

Three things.

Stay in touch, every week. The hiring manager, not just HR. A short call or a quick note: we’re glad you’re coming, here’s what the team’s working on, here’s who you’ll meet. Silence is where doubt grows. Every week you’re in touch, she feels a little more like part of your team and a little less like part of the old one.

Keep the start date close. Every extra week is another week for her current boss to find a better argument. Give the old job a fair notice period, and then start. If there’s a real reason for a longer gap, stay in touch even more.

Welcome her early. Invite her to lunch with the team. Ship the laptop before day one. Introduce her to her first project, so she’s already thinking about your problems instead of her old ones. People rarely go back once they’ve met the people they’ll miss.

Isn’t that a lot of attention for someone who already said yes?

It’s the cheapest attention you’ll ever pay. You spent weeks finding this person. A few calls and a lunch protect all of it. And it’s a lovely way to start: she arrives on day one already knowing faces, already curious about the work, already glad she chose you.

What if the counteroffer comes anyway?

Don’t panic, and don’t turn it into an auction. Remind her, gently, why she said yes: the work, the team, the boss. If you’ve stayed close, she’ll remember it on her own.

If you’re working with me, tell me right away. Engineers are often more candid with me than with a new boss, and I’ll remind her what she told me mattered.

The short version

  • Counteroffers rarely work for the engineer, and they cost you the hire either way.
  • The hiring manager stays in touch every week.
  • Keep the start date close.
  • Welcome them early: lunch with the team, the laptop shipped, an intro to their first project.
  • If a counteroffer comes, remind them why they said yes.

The offer gets the yes. The weeks after it keep it.

Making an offer soon?

Talk to Brian

Tell me what you need. I’ll think of someone.

Skip the formal job description. The more honest you are about the seat, the stack and the room, the faster a warm intro shows up. If I can help, great. If not, I’ll point you in the right direction.

Brian MarianiI read these myself. Jonathan Soo Hoo, my partner at Mirror, does the first outreach on some searches; if you hear from him, that’s why.

When do you need someone in the chair?

No sequence, no platform. A person reads this. Questions first? Read the FAQ.