Nobody likes saying no. Not after a good conversation, and not to someone who took a morning off to talk with you. So a lot of companies don’t say it. They say, “We’ll be in touch,” and then they go quiet.
The engineer is left wondering. Are they still deciding? Was it something I said? Should I follow up, or would that look desperate? Silence feels kinder in the moment. It’s actually the unkindest answer there is.
Why bother saying no?
Two reasons, and one of them is selfish.
The first is simple decency. Someone gave you their time and their hopes. They deserve an answer, and if you can manage it, a reason.
The second is that saying no makes you better at hiring. When you make yourself say exactly why someone isn’t right (“strong on the back end, but this seat needs someone who owns the front end”), you sharpen what you’re actually looking for. “Eh, not quite” won’t help you find the next person. A clear reason will.
What does a good no sound like?
Short, specific and kind. Something like: “We really enjoyed talking with you. You’re clearly strong on the back end, but this role needs someone who can own our front end from day one, so we’re going to pass. Thank you for your time.”
That’s it. Nobody’s left guessing, and nobody’s insulted.
What can a good no do for you?
Here’s the part people miss. The engineer you turned down knows other engineers. A week later, a friend mentions she’s thinking about a move, and she’s great at front-end work. If you told the first engineer why, he can say, “I talked to them. They need exactly what you do. You should call them.”
If you went quiet, the story goes differently: “Don’t bother. I interviewed there and never heard back.”
Engineering is a small world. Every person you interview becomes a reference for you or against you.
What if you hate making that call?
Then let me make it. It’s part of my job, and I’m glad to do it. Hiring managers often tell me the real reason more freely than they’d tell the engineer, and I can pass it along kindly and point the engineer toward a seat that fits better.
And if you’re an engineer who’s been left waiting, that’s one more reason to have someone in your corner. I can call the hiring manager and ask where things stand, and nobody thinks it’s rude.
The short version
- Silence isn’t kind. It just feels easier.
- Say no clearly and quickly, with one specific reason.
- A good no sharpens your search, and it can send you your next hire.
When an engineer who didn’t get the job says, “They were great about it,” that company has won something money can’t buy. Any company can earn that line.
Hiring a senior engineer? Tell me about the seat.
I read these myself. Jonathan Soo Hoo, my partner at Mirror, does the first outreach on some searches; if you hear from him, that’s why.