My favorite moment in this work is the call where I get to deliver the good news. A hiring manager has told me, “We’d love to have them on the team,” I pass it along, and I can hear the engineer smile. The week after that call is the one I worry about, because now the clock is running on both sides.
By the time you make an offer, everyone has paid for it. There were rounds of interviews, at least one on site. A code exercise or a pairing session. Reference calls. Hours pulled from everyone’s real work. You’re sold on the engineer, and the engineer is excited about the seat.
And still, offers die right here. I’ve watched it happen for twenty years, and the cause is almost always one of two things: small money or time. This note is about time. Small money has a note of its own.
What happens after a verbal offer?
The first offer is usually a phone call. “We like you, you like us, we’d love to have you.” The engineer says, “Great, send the paperwork.”
Then nothing. A day. Three days. A week.
The reasons always sound reasonable:
- Legal needs to draft the letter.
- We’re waiting on one more reference.
- The equity number needs a sign-off from the CEO, or the board.
- And the one nobody says out loud: now that we know you’re in, let’s see if someone better turns up.
Almost always, the delay comes from good people with full calendars. Nobody means to let it drift. Meanwhile, the engineer you want is getting other messages, and every quiet day, “we’d love to have you” sounds a little less true.
How fast should the written offer follow?
The same day. If you mean the verbal offer, a few phone calls and an hour’s work will put it on paper.
If you’re truly waiting on something, like a background check, put standard contingency language in the letter and send it anyway. Don’t hold the whole offer for one item.
I’ve seen this often enough that I steer engineers away from companies that let an offer sit for a week. A slow offer is usually a preview of everything else.
Doesn’t the engineer need time to decide?
Yes, and time kills from that side too. Once an offer is in hand, I hear:
- “I’m away this week.”
- “I need more time to think it over.”
- Nothing at all. The engineer goes quiet.
- And the unspoken one: “Now that I have an offer, let me shop it around, including to my current boss.”
A job change is a big decision. It touches a family, a commute and a team you’ll miss, and it deserves real thought. But most of that thinking belongs in the weeks of interviews, not after the offer arrives. By then you know the people, the work and the range.
So my advice to engineers is to answer within 48 hours: yes, no, or a clear counter. If you know sooner, say so sooner. There’s a whole note on that: You got the offer.
Why does speed matter so much?
A fast offer and a fast answer tell each side the same thing: we want this. That’s a good way to start working together.
A slow one plants doubt on both sides. Are they really excited? Did they find someone better? Is this how they make every decision?
The short version
- Put a verbal offer in writing the same day.
- If something’s pending, say so in the letter instead of holding the letter.
- Ask for an answer within two days, and mean it.
- Keep talking the whole time. Silence is where offers go to die.
Send the letter today. Then pick up the phone and tell them you can’t wait for them to start. You’ll mean it, and they’ll hear it.
Hiring a senior engineer? Tell me about the seat.
I read these myself. Jonathan Soo Hoo, my partner at Mirror, does the first outreach on some searches; if you hear from him, that’s why.