Brian’s Notes If you’re hiring

A balance scale tipped all the way down by one small coin, outweighing a signed offer letter on the other pan, beside an empty office chair

Short money.

Don’t lose a great hire over a small gap.

When an offer falls apart at the last minute, people assume it was over a big number. It almost never is. The deals I’ve watched die over money mostly died over a small gap: sometimes just a few thousand dollars between two people who badly wanted to work together.

It’s a shame every time, because by the offer stage the hard part is done. You’ve found someone with the skills you need and a personality that fits your team. They’ve found a seat they’re excited about. The range came up early, so nobody’s surprised. And then a gap the size of a rounding error stands between you.

Why does a small gap feel so big?

Because it’s rarely about the money. On the engineer’s side, I hear things like:

  • “I made this much at my last job, so my next one has to pay more.”
  • “My friend makes that, and I’m at least as good.”
  • “I’ve had a number in my head for a while.”

On the hiring side, I hear:

  • “Someone else on the team makes less. I can’t offer more than that.”
  • “That’s more than someone more senior makes.”
  • “That’s more than I make.”
  • “Our investors won’t let us.”

Every one of these is human, and none of them is crazy. But none of them is really about the person you’re trying to hire.

What should a hiring manager do with the gap?

Think about your team the way a good coach thinks about a roster. People join at different times, in different markets, and their pay reflects the day they signed. That isn’t unfair. It’s how teams get built. If someone already on your team is underpaid, fix that on its own merits. Don’t make your next great hire pay for it.

If you truly can’t move on salary, say so plainly, and look at the rest of the package: a signing bonus, equity, the start date, an early review. A creative answer closes gaps that a stubborn one never will.

And what should the engineer do?

By the offer stage, you’ve already decided the work and the range are exciting. Don’t let the last mile change your mind. A few thousand dollars a year, after taxes, comes to about a cup of coffee a day. Ask yourself whether that’s really why you’d walk away from something you want.

If the number truly matters, and sometimes it does, say why, and say it once. Then let your recruiter carry it. That’s what I’m for.

The short version

  • Small gaps kill more deals than big ones.
  • Find out what the gap is really about, on both sides.
  • Pay people for the market they joined in, and fix old gaps on their own.
  • Close the gap with the whole package, not just the salary line.

When both sides give a little, a few cups of coffee buy years of good work together.

Hiring a senior engineer? Tell me about the seat.

Talk to Brian

Tell me what you need. I’ll think of someone.

Skip the formal job description. The more honest you are about the seat, the stack and the room, the faster a warm intro shows up. If I can help, great. If not, I’ll point you in the right direction.

Brian MarianiI read these myself. Jonathan Soo Hoo, my partner at Mirror, does the first outreach on some searches; if you hear from him, that’s why.

When do you need someone in the chair?

No sequence, no platform. A person reads this. Questions first? Read the FAQ.